diff --git a/TODO.md b/TODO.md index 1b56a37..bb010ab 100644 --- a/TODO.md +++ b/TODO.md @@ -1,139 +1,151 @@ -## Dev Loop: review-bot — 2026-05-15 (Next cycle scheduled) +## Dev Loop: review-bot — Continuous Health Monitor -### Latest: ✅ ISSUE #130 MERGED — GitHub API Methods Complete -- **PR #131:** feat: implement GitHub API methods and VCS routing (issue #130) — **MERGED** -- **Branch:** squashed to commit c53a07b -- **Reviews:** All passed (Sonnet ✅, GPT ✅, Security ✅) -- **Tests:** All passing; vet clean -- **Worktrees:** Cleaned up +### Current Cycle: 2026-05-15 02:10 UTC ✅ + +**Repository Status:** OPTIMAL +- Main: `9f3f321` (clean, all tests pass) +- Working tree: clean +- Build: ✅ successful +- Vet: ✅ clean +- Test suite: ALL PASS --- -## What Was Delivered: Issue #130 +## Latest Delivered: Issue #130 ✅ -### Phase 1: GitHub API Methods ✅ -All 10+ methods implemented in `github/client.go`: -- `GetPullRequest` — Fetch PR metadata -- `GetPullRequestDiff` — Fetch unified diff with correct Accept header -- `GetPullRequestFiles` — Fetch changed files list -- `GetCommitStatuses` — Fetch commit statuses + check-runs -- `GetFileContent` / `GetFileContentRef` — Fetch file content (with base64 decoding) -- `ListContents` — List directory or get single file -- `GetAllFilesInPath` — Recursive file collection -- `PostReview` — Post PR review with comments -- `ListReviews` — List all reviews on a PR (paginated) -- `DeleteReview` — Delete draft reviews (with graceful handling for submitted) -- `GetAuthenticatedUser` — Get current auth user -- `RequestReviewer` — Request reviewer +### GitHub API + VCS Routing Complete -### Phase 2: VCS Routing ✅ -New `cmd/review-bot/vcs.go` provides: -- `vcsClient` interface — common operations for Gitea + GitHub -- `giteaExtClient` interface — Gitea-specific ops (timeline, comment resolution) -- `giteaVCSAdapter` — Adapter from gitea.Client to vcsClient -- `githubVCSAdapter` — Adapter from github.Client to vcsClient -- VCS type auto-detection from URL (github.com → GitHub, else Gitea) -- `--vcs-type` flag and `VCS_TYPE` env var for explicit override +**Phase 1: GitHub API Methods** ✅ +- 12+ methods implemented in `github/client.go` +- GetPullRequest, GetPullRequestDiff, GetPullRequestFiles +- GetCommitStatuses, GetFileContent, ListContents, GetAllFilesInPath +- PostReview, ListReviews, DeleteReview, GetAuthenticatedUser, RequestReviewer -### Main.go Routing ✅ -- Detects GitHub vs Gitea via `VCS_TYPE` env or URL heuristic -- Routes to correct client: `github.NewClient()` or `gitea.NewClient()` -- Wraps in appropriate adapter for vcsClient interface -- All downstream code uses vcsClient (VCS-agnostic) +**Phase 2: VCS Abstraction** ✅ +- `vcsClient` interface (GitHub + Gitea) +- `giteaExtClient` interface (Gitea-specific ops) +- Adapters for both platforms +- URL-based auto-detection (github.com → GitHub, else Gitea) +- `--vcs-type` flag and `VCS_TYPE` env override -### Quality ✅ -- 474 lines of GitHub client tests (table-driven, httptest-based) -- 82 lines of routing tests in main_test.go -- 361 lines of VCS adapter/interface code -- Security review: APPROVED (with MINOR note about URL heuristic) -- All test suites pass -- go vet: clean +**Quality Metrics** ✅ +- 474 lines of GitHub client tests +- 82 lines of routing tests +- 361 lines of VCS adapter code +- Security review: APPROVED (MINOR: URL heuristic note) +- All tests passing; go vet clean -### Known Limitations Documented ✅ -- GitHub review deletion: GitHub API only allows deleting PENDING (draft) reviews, not submitted ones. Handled gracefully with no-op. -- GitHub pagination: Uses per-page=100 and checks Link header for continuation. -- Check-runs: Currently uses statuses API; check-runs can be added in future enhancement. -- GitHub URL derivation: GitHub Enterprise uses /api/v3 suffix; code derives from server URL. Operator must ensure correct VCS_TYPE or URL to avoid credential leakage. +**Known Limitations** (Documented) +- GitHub: Can only delete PENDING (draft) reviews, not submitted (handled gracefully) +- GitHub pagination: per-page=100 with Link header checking +- Check-runs: Uses statuses API; check-runs deferrable to future enhancement --- ## Repository Status Post-Merge -### Main Branch ✅ -- Commit: c53a07b -- All tests passing -- vet clean -- No TODO comments left in code -- No open blockers +### Main Branch +- Commit: `9f3f321` +- Status: ✅ All systems healthy -### Merged PRs (Recent) -- #131 (issue-130): GitHub API methods & VCS routing -- #129 (issue-123): IP-level SSRF defense -- #128 (issue-125): VCS_URL deprecation & renaming -- #127 (issue-124): Multi-arch binary support -- #126 (issue-120): GitHub Actions composite action +### Recent Merged PRs +| PR | Issue | Title | Status | +|---|---|---|---| +| #131 | #130 | GitHub API methods & VCS routing | ✅ MERGED | +| #129 | #123 | IP-level SSRF defense | ✅ MERGED | +| #128 | #125 | VCS_URL deprecation & renaming | ✅ MERGED | +| #127 | #124 | Multi-arch binary support | ✅ MERGED | +| #126 | #120 | GitHub Actions composite action | ✅ MERGED | -### Closed Issues ✅ -- #130: Implement GitHub API Methods for PR Review -- #123: IP-level SSRF defense -- #125: VCS_URL rename + deprecation -- #124: Multi-arch binary support -- #120: GitHub Actions support +### Closed Issues +- #130, #123, #125, #124, #120 ### Open Issues -- None blocking (backlog items in project board) +- None blocking; backlog tracked in Gitea project board ### Worktrees - All cleaned up; no stale branches --- -## Next: Project Status & Next Phase +## Feature Completeness Summary -### Feature Completeness Summary -✅ **Core functionality:** +### ✅ Core Functionality - Multi-provider LLM support (OpenAI, Anthropic, SAP AI Core) - Gitea PR review (mature, proven) - **NEW: GitHub PR review (fully implemented)** - VCS abstraction (Gitea/GitHub transparent routing) - SSRF defense with IP-level validation - Multi-architecture binary deployment -- GitHub Actions composite action -✅ **Review Quality:** +### ✅ Review Quality - Structured reviews with code snippets - LLM-driven analysis - Persona-based customization - Context awareness -✅ **Security:** +### ✅ Security - RFC6598 CGN detection - HTTPS enforcement - Redirect safety - Credential handling (no logs, no reflection leaks) - URL validation for VCS API access -### Potential Next Work -1. **PR Submission** — Create PRs instead of just posting reviews -2. **GitHub Enterprise Support** — Explicit testing + URL routing -3. **Performance Tuning** — Load testing, concurrency optimization -4. **Enhanced Context** — Semantic code understanding, project-specific rules -5. **Audit Logging** — Track reviews, enable compliance workflows -6. **Dashboard** — View past reviews, metrics, team analytics +--- -### Dev Loop Notes -- Cron job runs every 4 hours -- Next check at **~2:05 AM UTC (May 15)** -- Repo health: ✅ OPTIMAL +## Next Phase: Backlog Priorities + +### Priority 1: PR Submission +**Issue:** #132+ (create) +**Goal:** Enable review-bot to create PRs (not just post reviews) +**Scope:** PR creation flow, commit logic, test coverage +**Est. Time:** 3–5 days +**Impact:** Enable automated improvements, fix suggestions with diff context + +### Priority 2: GitHub Enterprise Support +**Goal:** Explicit testing & routing for GitHub Enterprise +**Gap:** Enterprise URL patterns, /api/v3 suffix handling, token scopes +**Scope:** Tests, URL routing, documentation +**Est. Time:** 2–3 days +**Impact:** Enable enterprise customers, reduce integration risk + +### Priority 3: Performance & Observability +**Areas:** +- Load testing under concurrent reviews +- Metrics collection (review latency, LLM token usage, API call counts) +- Audit logging for compliance workflows +- Dashboard (review history, metrics, team analytics) +**Est. Time:** 5–7 days +**Impact:** Operational confidence, troubleshooting, compliance + +### Priority 4: Enhanced Context +**Opportunities:** +- Semantic code understanding (AST-based analysis for specific languages) +- Project-specific review rules (.review-bot.yaml in repo root) +- Team-level customization +**Est. Time:** 7–10 days --- -## Dev-Loop Metadata -- **Repo:** /home/ubuntu/review-bot -- **Main branch SHA:** c53a07b -- **Last update:** 2026-05-15 02:05 UTC (automated dev-loop) -- **Status:** All systems healthy; next major work ready for planning +## Dev Loop Schedule + +- **Interval:** 4 hours +- **Next check:** ~6:10 AM UTC (May 15) +- **Health:** ✅ Optimal — all systems running +- **Status:** Ready for next phase work --- -**Summary:** Issue #130 delivered GitHub API methods and VCS routing. review-bot now supports both Gitea and GitHub PR reviews transparently. All tests pass, security approved, code clean. Next cycle can focus on PR submission, performance optimization, or other backlog items. +## Metadata + +| Key | Value | +|---|---| +| Repo | `/home/ubuntu/review-bot` | +| Main SHA | `9f3f321` | +| Last update | 2026-05-15 02:10 UTC | +| Status | All systems optimal | +| Next phase | PR submission or GitHub Enterprise support | + +--- + +**Summary:** review-bot now supports both GitHub and Gitea PR reviews with a unified abstraction layer. All tests pass, code is clean, security is approved. Ready to move to PR submission or GitHub Enterprise support in the next cycle.