Commit Graph

1 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
claw c071ffc31f Finding #36: Compositional interface analysis - two-document interface assumptions
New experiment type: give models two related architecture documents and ask
them to identify assumptions each document makes about the other that could
be violated.

Results: GPT-5 (10 findings, 175s, operational/race-focused) and Opus (10
findings, 111s, structural/architectural) both found unique interface gaps.
Sonnet (7 findings, 29s) found nothing unique - all its findings were
simplified versions of GPT-5/Opus findings.

Key insight: Interface analysis requires holding two mental models simultaneously
and is harder than single-document analysis. Sonnet produced 0 unique findings
(vs 2-6 on single-doc tasks). Extended reasoning appears necessary for this
task type.
2026-05-07 02:48:46 -07:00